Payment Gateway Flexibility: WooCommerce and Shopify Side by Side

Reading Time: 3 minutes

When it comes to accepting payments online, the choice between WooCommerce and Shopify can significantly impact your costs, customer experience, and business flexibility. While both platforms can process payments effectively, they take fundamentally different approaches to payment gateway integration – and understanding these differences could save you thousands of dollars while improving your customers’ checkout experience.

What Is a Payment Gateway and Why Does It Matter?

A payment gateway is the technology that securely captures and transfers payment information between your online store, your customer’s bank, and your merchant account. Think of it as the digital equivalent of a credit card terminal in a physical store – it’s the bridge that makes online transactions possible.

But payment gateways do much more than just process payments:

Security: They encrypt sensitive payment data and ensure PCI compliance, protecting both you and your customers from fraud and data breaches.

Payment Method Support: Different gateways support different payment methods – credit cards, digital wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay), bank transfers, buy-now-pay-later services, and regional payment methods.

Global Reach: Some gateways specialize in specific regions or currencies, while others offer global coverage with local payment method support.

Fees and Pricing: Gateway fees can vary significantly – from flat per-transaction fees to percentage-based charges, monthly fees, and setup costs.

Features and Integrations: Advanced features like recurring billing, fraud detection, detailed reporting, and integration with accounting systems.

Customer Experience: The checkout flow, payment form design, and supported payment methods directly impact conversion rates and customer satisfaction.

Business Intelligence: Transaction data, customer insights, and reporting capabilities that help you understand and optimize your business.

Choosing the right payment gateway isn’t just about accepting payments – it’s about optimizing costs, improving customer experience, and supporting your business model effectively.

Supported Payment Gateways

Feature	WooCommerce	Shopify
Number of Gateways	100+	100+
Default Gateway	None (choose your own)	Shopify Payments
Major Third-Party Options	Stripe, PayPal, Square, Authorize.Net, Klarna, Afterpay, and more	Stripe, PayPal, Authorize.Net, Amazon Pay, and more
Local Gateways	Widely supported via plugins	Some limitations by country
Crypto Support	Yes, via third-party plugins	Limited, not natively supported

🟢 WooCommerce wins on flexibility. You can choose from a huge number of gateways and install plugins to support even niche or regional options.

🟡 Shopify has solid support, but is more opinionated (especially if you want to use something other than Shopify Payments).

---

Fees & Transaction Costs

Cost Factor	WooCommerce	Shopify
Platform Transaction Fees	None	0.5%–2% if you don’t use Shopify Payments
Gateway Transaction Fees	Varies by gateway	Varies by gateway
Additional Charges	Hosting, plugin costs	Monthly subscription + app fees

🟢 WooCommerce is often more affordable long-term—especially if you’re using your own preferred payment gateway.

🔴 Shopify charges extra transaction fees unless you use their in-house solution, Shopify Payments. This can add up fast for high-volume stores.

---

Customization & Integration

Feature	WooCommerce	Shopify
Custom Payment Integrations	Fully customizable (open source)	Limited without Shopify Plus
Developer Access	Full code access	Restricted codebase
Plugin Ecosystem	Thousands of free/paid options	Strong app store, but many are paid
Ideal For	Complex workflows, niche payment setups	Quick setups, minimal customization

🟢 With WooCommerce, we can build nearly anything. Need to route payments based on product type? Want to support offline invoices? No problem.

🟡 Shopify is great for out-of-the-box needs, but if you want something bespoke, you’re often forced into workarounds—or higher tiers.

---

Global Commerce & Currencies

Feature	WooCommerce	Shopify
Multi-Currency Support	Yes, with plugins or WooCommerce Payments	Yes, with Shopify Payments or apps
International Gateway Options	Broadly supported	Country-limited (based on Shopify Payments availability)
Language Flexibility	Fully multilingual with plugins	Requires apps or Plus plan

🟢 WooCommerce gives you global freedom—choose the gateway that works in your country or language, with no platform restrictions.

🟡 Shopify supports multi-currency, but your experience may depend heavily on Shopify Payments availability in your region.

Making the Right Payment Decision

Choose Shopify for Payments if:

• You want simple, integrated payment processing
• You’re comfortable with Shopify Payments’ industry restrictions
• You prioritize ease of setup over cost optimization
• You don’t need specialized payment methods or custom workflows

Choose WooCommerce for Payments if:

• You want to minimize transaction fees and maximize gateway choices
• You need specialized payment methods or custom payment workflows
• You’re selling internationally and need local payment method support
• You have technical resources to manage payment gateway complexity

The Bottom Line

While Shopify offers simplicity and integration, WooCommerce provides unmatched flexibility and cost optimization potential. The choice depends on your business model, technical capabilities, and long-term growth plans.

For businesses with standard payment needs and a preference for simplicity, Shopify’s integrated approach works well. For businesses requiring specialized payment methods, cost optimization, or custom payment workflows, WooCommerce’s flexibility provides significant advantages.

Remember, payment processing is often one of your largest operational costs, so choosing the right approach can have a substantial impact on your bottom line.

---

Ready to optimize your payment processing strategy? At Built Mighty, we specialize in WooCommerce payment gateway integration and optimization. From cost analysis to custom payment workflows, we help businesses choose and implement the right payment solutions for their needs. Visit us at builtmighty.com to learn how we can help streamline your payment processing while reducing costs.